Friday, October 23, 2020

Texas attorney and client found guilty of IRS fraud, tax evasion


According to this press release from the U.S. Department of Justice, a jury has convicted John O. Green, a Texas attorney apparently located in Athens, Texas, and Thomas Selgas, his client and apparently also his business partner, of conspiracy to defraud the United States.

The evidence showed that Selgas and his wife owed the IRS approximately $1.1 million in outstanding taxes, which Selgas simply refused to pay. Instead, Selgas persuaded Green to let him use Green’s attorney trust account (commonly known as an IOLTA account) as, basically, Selgas’ personal piggy bank for receiving income and paying personal expenses and credit card bills.

Additionally, Selgas and Green filed a false tax return on behalf of their company, MyMail, Ltd., which was described as an intellectual property development and licensing partnership. Looking at the indictment filed July 18, 2018, it is alleged that MyMail settled lawsuits against various internet service providers for about $6.8 million, of which Selgas received a distribution of $1.1 million.

Selgas was apparently determined not to pay taxes no matter what, and refused to file accurate returns. In one of his tax disputes, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit observed that:

- Advertisement -

“Selgas’s arguments are utterly lacking in merit and, as an aside, his conduct in this litigation appears to have been inconsistent with that of a litigant endeavoring to aid in the truthful and efficient resolution of contested issues of fact and law. We have no sympathy for Selgas’s behavior or his arguments in defense of what appears to have been a brazen attempt to avoid a few thousand dollars in legitimate tax liability.” Selgas v. Comm’r, 475 F.3d 697, 701 (5th Cir. 2007)


Even though the Bar Associations spend a tremendous amount of time every year warning attorneys not to misuse — or let their clients misuse — their attorney trust accounts, we still see stories like these.

An attorney trust account is not that just in name, but really is an account for client moneys (and strictly client moneys) that are to be applied towards the particular legal matter that the attorney is handling for the client; exactly no more, and exactly no less.

- Advertisement -

Green was not holding Selgas’ money for that proper purpose. Instead, Green misused his attorney trust account to allow Selgas to hide money from the IRS, as demonstrated by the fact that Green used the money to pay Selgas’ personal expenses and credit cards, etc., which had utterly nothing to do with the legal matters that Green was handling for Selgas at the time.

Probably every attorney will run across the situation at least once where a client cannot open an account for himself (almost always because of very bad reasons) and thus attempts to persuades the attorney to allow him to misuse the attorney’s trust account. As difficult as it may be to resist at the time, the attorney’s answer must be a firm “No. Hell no“.

Here, Green and Selgas apparently had a non-legal business relationship that made Green sympathetic to Selgas’ situation and eventually lead him to allow Selgas to misuse his attorney trust account. If anything, this demonstrates why attorneys should not be involved in business deals with their clients ⸺ that is generally a terrible idea even if the ethical rules strictly allow it.

Even devoid of the very serious ethical problems, allowing Selgas to do what Green did makes utterly no business sense. Green is about to spend hard time in Club Fed, and the State Bar of Texas will undoubtedly punch his ticket to practice law in a very permanent fashion. From Green’s state bar profile page, it appears that Green was licensed in Texas the same year that I was (1993), and so likely had at least 10 years in front of him practicing law. In those 10 years, how much in fees would he have earned?

If Selgas didn’t pay him at least that much in fees (and I doubt very much that it came to even a small fraction of that amount), it was a very bad business decision by Green.

Crazy, really.



Goldman Sachs executives to cover part payments of $3 billion fines in 1MDB scandal

Nine current or former Goldman Sachs executives, including CEO David Solomon, will have to pay back hundreds of millions of dollars in compensation over...

Goldman Sachs agrees $3 billion settlement with US DoJ over 1MDB corruption scandal

Goldman Sachs has agreed to pay nearly $3bn (£2.3bn) in the US to end a probe of its role in Malaysia's 1MDB corruption scandal. The...

Hong Kong fines Goldman Sachs $350 million over 1MDB scandal

Goldman Sachs ignored multiple red flags over the multibillion-dollar fundraisings it arranged for state fund 1Malaysia Development Berhad, Hong Kong’s financial regulator said on...

Texas attorney general Ken Paxton fires top aide who accused him of bribery

Lacey Mase, one of the top aides who accused Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton of crimes including bribery and abuse of office, has been fired, she told The...

Fundraiser Elliott Broidy pleads guilty in foreign agent case linked to 1MDB

Major Republican Party and Trump fundraiser Elliott Broidy pleaded guilty Tuesday to acting as an unregistered foreign agent, admitting to accepting millions...

Latest News

This Week

Texas AG Ken Paxton fires second whistleblower who accused him of bribery

A second whistleblower has been fired from the Texas attorney general’s office after reporting his boss, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, to law enforcement for...

Federal prosecutors seek 24-30 months in prison for ex-Cincinnati Councilwoman Tamaya Dennard in bribery case

Because of the seriousness of the bribery scheme in which she was involved, former Cincinnati Councilwoman Tamaya Dennard should go to federal prison for 24 to...

Australian court approves $920 million Westpac money laundering fine

The Federal Court of Australia has agreed on the deal struck between the Australian Transaction Reports and Analysis Centre (AUSTRAC) and Westpac, ordering the Australian...

Ex-managers of Security firm pleads guilty in Santa Clara County concealed gun permit bribery scandal

Two former managers of a Silicon Valley international security firm pleaded guilty Monday to charges related to a bribery scheme to obtain concealed firearms...

Adblock Detected!

Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors. Please consider supporting us by whitelisting our website.

Enable Notifications    Ok No thanks