Friday, October 23, 2020

Irish corruption law not in compliance with OECD guidelines


A law introduced by Ireland last year, as part of an international drive aimed at combatting corruption, has been found not to be in compliance with the convention guiding the project, the Department of Justice has confirmed.

The Criminal Justice (Corruption Practices) Act 2018 made it an offence to be involved in foreign corruption. Among other matters, the law covers bribery abroad by businesses based in the State and provides for fines without limit for companies found guilty.

However, the Irish law includes a requirement that the offence be a crime both in Ireland and in the country where the bribery allegedly occurred, a requirement called “dual criminality”.

Related: OECD Publishes Follow-up Report on UK’s Implementation of Anti-Bribery Convention

Ireland is a full member of the OECD’s Working Group on Bribery and a party to the Convention on Combating Bribery of Foreign Public Officials in International Business Transactions. The law was introduced last year in part to give effect to the 1997 convention.

- Advertisement -

According to the OECD, the anti-bribery convention is the only existing multilateral instrument aimed at combatting “the supply side” of foreign bribery, meaning that it targets the parties making the corrupt payments.

Article one

“The text of the OECD Convention is silent on the issue of dual criminality,” a spokesman for the Department of Justice said.

However, in a recent stocktaking study by the OECD on the implementation of the convention, “the working group found that dual criminality requirements for the foreign bribery offence by their very nature compel the consideration of foreign law and its application to the facts of the case.

“They are hence inconsistent with article one of the convention, which requires an autonomous foreign bribery offence. “

- Advertisement -

The spokesman said that Minister for Justice Charlie Flanagan acted on the advice of the Attorney General that Ireland exercises extraterritorial jurisdiction on the basis that dual criminality is required.

The Irish law is to be evaluated by the OECD in October.

“Ireland will consider fully any recommendations that the working group makes from that evaluation,” the spokesman said.

Related: OECD Cites Germany Over Corporate Bribery Enforcement

A spokeswoman for the OECD said it would be in a much better position to comment on the Irish law after the review.

Bribery abroad

Ireland has never prosecuted an act of foreign corruption. A document published last November by the OECD shows that Ireland, which accounts for 1.68 per cent of the world’s total exports, has never sanctioned or attempted to sanction a person or a company for bribery abroad.

Germany, by way of comparison, accounts for 7.86 per cent of world exports, and has sanctioned 316 individuals and 11 companies for foreign bribery.

The Garda National Economic Crime Bureau – which investigates corruption both at home and abroad – noted the dual criminality problem in a letter to the department last year.

“If Irish persons or companies are operating in a jurisdiction where anti-corruption legislation is weak or non-existent, then no offence occurs, which appears to go against the whole ethos of the OECD convention on foreign bribery and corruption,” the letter pointed out.

“It is our duty in the developed world to do everything in our power to ensure that our citizens and businesses are not engaged in bribery and corruption.”


Goldman Sachs agrees $3 billion settlement with US DoJ over 1MDB corruption scandal

Goldman Sachs has agreed to pay nearly $3bn (£2.3bn) in the US to end a probe of its role in Malaysia's 1MDB corruption scandal. The...

Hong Kong fines Goldman Sachs $350 million over 1MDB scandal

Goldman Sachs ignored multiple red flags over the multibillion-dollar fundraisings it arranged for state fund 1Malaysia Development Berhad, Hong Kong’s financial regulator said on...

Texas attorney general Ken Paxton fires top aide who accused him of bribery

Lacey Mase, one of the top aides who accused Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton of crimes including bribery and abuse of office, has been fired, she told The...

Fundraiser Elliott Broidy pleads guilty in foreign agent case linked to 1MDB

Major Republican Party and Trump fundraiser Elliott Broidy pleaded guilty Tuesday to acting as an unregistered foreign agent, admitting to accepting millions...

Germany issues international arrest warrant for founders of law firm at the centre of Panama Papers

Germany has issued international arrest warrants for the two founders of the firm at the centre of the tax haven scandal exposed by the...

Latest News

This Week

Ex-CEO of dietary supplement maker USPLabs sentenced to prison in fraud case

They wanted to lose weight and get stronger to boost their military careers. But after taking USPLabs' dietary supplements – with ingredients made in...

Germany issues international arrest warrant for founders of law firm at the centre of Panama Papers

Germany has issued international arrest warrants for the two founders of the firm at the centre of the tax haven scandal exposed by the...

Wells Fargo fires more than 100 workers over abuse of COVID-19 relief funds

Wells Fargo & Co has fired about 100 to 125 employees for unethically availing themselves of coronavirus relief funds, according to a source familiar...

UAE suspends licences of 200 law firms over anti-money laundering compliance

Practicing licences of 200 law firms in the UAE have been suspended for a month for not following the prescribed procedures to combat money...

Adblock Detected!

Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors. Please consider supporting us by whitelisting our website.

Enable Notifications    Ok No thanks